Why do drywall cracks keep coming back even after I patch them?

Cracks often reappear when the root issue isn't addressed — things like settling foundation, humidity changes, loose framing, or moisture. A good repair job means not just patching the surface, but checking what’s behind it and using proper materials.

How much is this going to cost — I'm worried about hidden fees?

I always provide a written estimate up front that includes all materials, labor, and clean-up. No surprise add-ons. We talk through everything so you know what to expect.

Can you match the existing wall texture/finish so the repair doesn’t show?

Absolutely. Matching texture is one of the things homeowners care most about. Whether smooth, knockdown, orange peel, or another finish, I make sure the repair blends seamlessly.

How long will the repair take, and when can you start?

It depends on the size of the job. Small repairs may take hours, larger jobs require more time for drying and finishing. I provide a clear schedule and stick to it.

What if I only need a small repair — is it worth hiring a pro?

Yes — even small holes or cracks, if repaired poorly, will show up. A patch done right ensures durability, blends texture, and keeps your space clean.

How do you protect my home and clean up after the job?

I use drop-cloths, plastic sheeting, protect floors and furniture, and always clean up dust and debris. Pets and kids are taken into account for safety.

What causes drywall damage like water stains, bulges, or ceiling sagging?

These issues are usually due to moisture from leaks or poor ventilation. I inspect behind the drywall to fix the cause and ensure long-lasting repairs.

Will you provide a guarantee or warranty on the work?

Yes. I guarantee my repairs — if an issue arises from my work, I’ll come back and fix it at no extra cost.

Are you licensed/insured?

Yes — I maintain all required insurance and follow Massachusetts codes for your protection and peace of mind.

Do you offer any discounts (senior, multi-room, etc.)?

Yes, I offer discounts for seniors and multi-room projects. We’ll discuss options to give you the best value.

Drywall vs Plaster: Pros, Cons, and What’s Best for Older Homes in Western MA

Introduction

If you own an older home in Western Massachusetts, chances are your walls are plaster rather than drywall. Many historic houses in Easthampton, Northampton, and surrounding towns were built before drywall became the standard. Now, as homeowners renovate or repair, one big question often comes up: stick with plaster, or switch to drywall?

This decision affects cost, durability, appearance, and even the resale value of your home. In this article, we’ll compare plaster and drywall side by side, highlighting the pros and cons of each, and provide guidance for homeowners in Western MA looking to preserve their home’s character while updating for modern living.

Understanding drywall and plaster

Drywall

Drywall, also called gypsum board or sheetrock, became popular in the mid-20th century because it was faster and cheaper to install than plaster. It comes in panels that are screwed to wall studs, then taped, mudded, and sanded for a smooth finish.

Key traits of drywall:

Cost-effective and widely available
Easier and quicker to install
Compatible with modern insulation and electrical work
Repair is straightforward

Plaster

Plaster is the traditional wall material used before drywall became common. It is applied in layers over wooden lath strips or metal mesh. Plaster walls are thicker, harder, and often found in older homes with historical value.

Key traits of plaster:

Dense, hard surface with classic appearance
Superior soundproofing compared to drywall
Adds value in historic homes if preserved well
Repairs are more labor-intensive and costly

Pros and cons of drywall vs plaster

When choosing between drywall and plaster for an older home, weigh the following:

Pros of drywall

Lower cost for both material and labor
Faster installation during remodels
Easier to cut into for running new wiring or insulation
Simple patching and repairs

Cons of drywall

Less durable against dents and impact compared to plaster
Provides less natural sound insulation
Lacks the classic “solid wall” feel of plaster

Pros of plaster

Extremely durable and resistant to wear
Superior acoustic qualities, reducing noise between rooms
Adds charm and authenticity to historic homes
Provides thicker, more solid walls

Cons of plaster

Expensive to repair or replace
Requires specialized skills for proper application
Susceptible to cracks over time, especially in older houses with settling
Time-consuming installation if rebuilding entire walls

How to decide what’s best for your older Western MA home

Making the drywall vs plaster decision involves more than just budget. Here’s a process to guide you:

Step 1: Consider the age and character of your home

If you live in a historic property and want to preserve authenticity, repairing plaster may be worthwhile. If resale value or preserving historic charm matters, plaster often wins.

Step 2: Factor in the scope of your renovation

Small repairs: Matching existing plaster may be the best route.
Major remodel or addition: Drywall is faster and more practical for new construction.

Step 3: Think about performance needs

For soundproofing and durability, plaster still has the edge.
For affordability, insulation upgrades, and convenience, drywall is more practical.

Step 4: Weigh local climate and maintenance

Massachusetts winters can be hard on older plaster walls, leading to cracking. Drywall handles seasonal expansion and contraction better, though it is less impact-resistant overall.

Step 5: Get professional advice

A drywall contractor familiar with older Western MA homes can evaluate your walls and recommend whether plaster repair, drywall replacement, or even a hybrid approach (drywall with skim coat plaster finish) works best.

FAQs

Is plaster stronger than drywall?
Yes, plaster is harder and denser, making it more durable against scratches and dents. However, it is more prone to cracking with age.
Can you put drywall over plaster?
Yes. Many homeowners install drywall over existing plaster walls as a cost-effective way to refresh without removing the old material.
Which is better for soundproofing, plaster or drywall?
Plaster generally provides better soundproofing because of its thickness and density. However, modern soundproof drywall options can close that gap.
Does drywall lower the value of a historic home?
Replacing plaster with drywall can reduce authenticity, which may affect value for buyers seeking historic charm. In most cases, careful drywall upgrades won’t hurt value if done tastefully.
Can plaster walls be repaired instead of replaced?
Yes. Skilled contractors can patch, skim coat, or restore plaster. Repairs are labor-intensive but can preserve the look of historic walls.

Conclusion

For homeowners in Western Massachusetts, the choice between drywall and plaster depends on balancing history with practicality. Plaster offers authenticity, charm, and durability — but at a higher cost and maintenance level. Drywall offers convenience, affordability, and ease of integration with modern living.

Frenchie Drywall in Easthampton works with both materials, helping homeowners preserve the beauty of their older homes while ensuring walls are safe, functional, and long-lasting. Whether you want to repair plaster or install new drywall, expert guidance ensures the best outcome for your unique property.

< Older Post Newer Post >